What do you all think? I want to know your point of view on this. Is it permissible for a woman to go out on the streets, hitting her chest, reciting nohas in a loud voice, and chanting “Labbayk Ya Hussain” in the presence of non-mahrams (both Shia and non-Shia)? Especially when non-mahram men, who are not Shia, are watching and taking pleasure in seeing this act performed by Shia women. Is this the essence of Muharram? Is this how the women from the household of Ahlulbayt spread the message of Hussain (a.s.)? Isn’t this against our moral values? Another point is that processions are heavily crowded, and whether intentionally or unintentionally, the shoulders and bodies of non-mahram men and women touch each other. What’s your take on this?
(Note: Bibi Zaynab was forcefully taken through the streets of Kufa and Shaam, not willingly. Also, the example of her khutbah in the court of Yazid is irrelevant in this situation.)
بِسْمِ اللهِ الرَّحْمٰنِ الرَّحِيْمِ
I might be wrong but certainly in my view ,commemorating Imam Hussain (as) during Muharram is a deeply significant practice that keeps his teachings alive not just during this month but throughout the year. However, certain practices, such as women publicly hitting their chests, reciting nohas loudly, and chanting ‘Labbayk Ya Hussain’ in the presence of non-mahrams, raise ethical concerns. Islam emphasizes modesty and respect for others, regardless of religious affiliation. Actions that could be perceived as provocative or cause discomfort to non-Shia observers may not effectively convey the message of Karbala with the dignity it deserves.
Reflecting on the dignity and restraint exemplified by Bibi Zaynab (sa) in adversity suggests that honoring Imam Hussain’s legacy should be done in ways that uphold Islamic values of modesty and respect for all.
Moreover, maintaining modesty and avoiding unnecessary physical contact between non-mahram men and women during Muharram processions (juloos) is crucial. Both intentional and unintentional physical contact should be avoided, as it aligns with Islamic teachings on maintaining boundaries and preserving dignity.
In summary, while commemorating Imam Hussain (as) and keeping his message alive is important, it should be done in a manner that respects Islamic principles of modesty, dignity, and consideration for others, regardless of their religious background. This approach not only upholds the values Imam Hussain stood for but also fosters a respectful environment that reflects positively on the broader community.