Sign Up to University of Ahlulbayt to ask questions, answer people's questions, and connect with other people.
Welcome to the University of Ahlulbayt Online Portal. Please log in with your university credentials to access courses, resources, and services. If you don't have an account, click below to sign up.
Lost your password? Please enter your email address. You will receive a link and will create a new password via email.
Please briefly explain why you feel this question should be reported.
Please briefly explain why you feel this answer should be reported.
Please briefly explain why you feel this user should be reported.
Is a Sunni nikah considered valid for a Shia? Similarly, if a Sunni girl has married a Sunni man and now wishes to marry a Shia man, is it necessary to revoke (talaq) the Sunni nikah? And vice versa, what is the requirement?
I actually asked because I recently learned that many Sunni Muslims do not consider Shia nikah valid. So they made a Shia girl marry someone Sunni without talaq from her husband who was Shia lol. The Molvi said it is not valid anyways.
The differences between Sunni and Shia nikah (marriage) ceremonies are rooted in their distinct interpretations of Islamic teachings and traditions. Here are some key differences:
1. **Witnesses**:
– **Sunni**: Requires two male witnesses or one male and two female witnesses.
– **Shia**: Requires two male witnesses.
2. **Temporary Marriage**:
– **Sunni**: Temporary marriage (Mut’ah) is not recognized and is considered impermissible.
– **Shia**: Mut’ah (temporary marriage) is permissible under specific conditions.
3. **Dowry (Mahr)**:
– Both Sunni and Shia practices require the giving of mahr (dowry) to the bride, but the customs surrounding it can vary.
4. **Nikah Khutbah (Sermon)**:
– **Sunni**: Often includes a sermon that consists of recitations from the Quran and Hadith.
– **Shia**: The sermon might be less formal and can include supplications and blessings specific to Shia traditions.
5. **Consent**:
– Both sects require the consent of both parties, but the methods of obtaining and expressing this consent can differ.
6. **Guardian’s Consent (Wali)**:
– **Sunni**: The presence and consent of a guardian (wali) for the bride is generally required.
– **Shia**: The consent of a guardian is preferred but not mandatory if the bride is mature and capable of making her own decisions.
7. **Recitations and Rituals**:
– **Sunni**: The ceremony may include specific prayers and recitations from the Quran.
– **Shia**: The ceremony might also include specific prayers and may involve additional rituals unique to Shia practice.
While both Sunni and Shia Muslims share many core beliefs and practices, these differences in their nikah ceremonies reflect their broader theological and jurisprudential distinctions.
In Shia Islam, a Sunni nikah (marriage contract) is considered valid, as the fundamental elements of the marriage contract (ijab, qubul, mahr, and witnesses) are the same in both Sunni and Shia traditions.
However, there are some considerations:
1. *Validity*: A Sunni nikah is valid for a Shia, but the marriage might not be recognized as a “ja’fari” marriage (a marriage contracted according to Shia jurisprudence). This could have implications for inheritance, child custody, and other legal matters.
2. *Revocation*: If a Sunni girl married to a Sunni man wants to marry a Shia man, she would need to obtain a divorce (talaq) from her Sunni husband or seek a khul’a (divorce initiated by the wife) before marrying the Shia man. This is because Shia Islam does not recognize a triple talaq (instant divorce) pronounced by a Sunni husband.
3. *Vice versa*: If a Shia girl married to a Shia man wants to marry a Sunni man, she would also need to obtain a divorce or khul’a from her Shia husband before marrying the Sunni man.
4. *Requirements*: For a Shia man to marry a Sunni woman, or vice versa, the following conditions apply:
a. The marriage contract must be executed according to the Shia or Sunni tradition, respectively.
b. The bride and groom must be aware of and agree to the terms of the marriage contract.
c. The marriage must be witnessed by two just and upright witnesses (according to Shia or Sunni requirements).
It’s important to note that these considerations may vary depending on individual circumstances and the specific madhab (school of thought) or interpretation. It’s recommended to consult with a knowledgeable Islamic scholar or authority for guidance on such matters.